Pages

Sunday, 15 September 2013

September 2013

Here's the latest set of images from member's of Circle D of the Leica Society. Enjoy.

1) Bernd H
Storm: Taken on a day after a heavy storm on the coast of Wangerooge Island, North Sea. M9, Summilux 50 ASPH, 10-Stop-ND-Filter, 12 sec
2) Bill S
No stopping today:  Taken with a Leica 3f and prewar 50mm Summar on Kodak 5302 copy film. This is rated at ISO 6 (needs a sunny day and fast lens!)  which is developed by inspection for around 4 minutes under safelight conditions in print developer. Scanned and slightly tweaked in Elements 9.

3) Dan B
Model: Joy - lit by one light as shown - M9 and 50mm Summilux pre-asph.

4) David F
Tattoo patterns: M3 + 9cm Summicron Fuji Sensia 200

5) David K
Awaiting a Tidal Surge' - Uphill, near Weston-super-Mare.  It was taken with my Leica M9 with 28mm Elmarit f/2.8 Lens - exposed for 1/350 second at  f/6.7  (ISO 160).

6) Duncan K
The Quiet Man'  … Philosophy Group Organiser at the end of  the Peterborough U3A Recruiting Day. His names list is full.  Leica X1 1/40sec f4 ISO 400

7) Elaine J
Divergent '  taken with a Lumix ZF100 with a leica lens.

8) Howard F
Stags in Bradgate Park which we came across on an August Bank Holiday walk.  They seemed quite comfortable with me edging closer to them and this is a 90mm shot.

9) James C
Meeting at the Midland,  DC Vario Elmarit FZ 48

10) Keith M
No image this month as travelling


11) Keith W
Keeping cool"  Leica M(240)/Summilux 50mm

12) Malcolm R
"Maiden Castle" Taken on my Panasonic on a dull day and converted to monochrome.

13) Michael E
This is a street shot from Mykonos town on a lazy summer morning. I like the interaction of the four humans: Artist as pleased as Punch with his creation and his Mickey Mouse tee shirt, admiring friend in rapt attention, mother disappearing into the foliage and child in tantrum for want of attention. The painted stone paving is typical of Mykonos streets as previous visitors will know. This is actually in the middle of a busy street, not in a courtyard. Taken with a Leica Monochrom and 75mm APO Summicron; pp in Silvefex Pro. There is some dust on the sensor (in case anyone notices, I do know) but it is fairly well disguised in the busy background. Dusty Greek islands are not the places to change M lenses. He is the French artist Georges Michel Elzar who spends the summer months painting in Mykonos.

14) Phil C
7 people, 6 legs, 1 broken: Leica M6


15) Robert H
Steve Hart And Prize Angus : Monmouth Show 2013 : M9P 35mm Summicron

16) Rob S
Anti-EDL Demo - X1


17) Theodore D
Out to pasture Leica 3.8 24mm w/Sony Nex-5
18) Tony M
'Dunham Massey Park' M8 + lightroom processing - IR with Helopan 695 cut filter


That's it once more. A good collection and a wide range of styles of photography.

Can all members please let me have a note with their favourite image and of course prepare for next month as it will be here in no time. Comments as well can be uploaded or emailed to me.

Best wishes.

15 comments:

  1. Duncan Kirkwood Circle D September Comments

    1. Bernd H: Storm

    I like the dynamics of the composition i.e. the use of the diagonal to emphasise the groynes – but I’ve seen rather too many ‘water with long exposure via ND filter’ images; they have to be really striking to make the grade. This image is fine in the foreground and has a pleasing glow on the horizon – but looks rather too overdone in the surf and underdone in the sky.

    2. Bill S: No stopping today

    Full marks for all the work and technique in this image. However, the soft focus does not seem to suit the subject and the lower RHS appears rather too dark to my eyes. I’m imagining what the technique and the lens could produce with a portrait – could be a superb tool set for portraiture.

    3. Dan B: Model – Joy

    Unfortunately the image is rather too small to assess fully and fairly. The lighting effect on the model and the creative use of the light source in the frame, is excellent. However, the model’s pose looks very tense, contrived and awkward – and probably does not adequately communicate what appears to be a superb physique. I’d prefer to see more of her femininity – she looks too masculine in this pose.

    4. David F: Tattoo patterns

    Good record shot of a ‘tattoo fail’ but I’d like to see more of her face and a more box office facial expression with the overdone lipstick. I do not know if this was a grab shot but there could have been a lot of potential (with a willing subject) to take a whole series of the lady and thus explore other poses … especially with the cigarette used more strategically. The figures creeping into the RHS are distracting and could be eliminated in post processing.

    5. David K: Awaiting a Tidal Surge

    Excellent record of low tide calmness and the anticipated surge. The sky is not so interesting – but on another day at a different time it could result in a very different picture.

    6. DSK: mine

    7. Elaine J: Divergent

    I like the simplicity of the dynamics of the composition and the colour – a very effective, artistic and pleasing image. Superb!

    8. Howard F: Stags in Bradgate Park

    A good record/habitat shot of a group of Fallow Deer bucks (not stags) congregating - but I’d like to see the species mentioned in the title.

    9. James C: Meeting at the Midland

    Image dimensions are a bit on the small side. A minimalist but graphic image as regards the dynamics of the architecture – but the seated couple do not blend in so well – maybe because of his uninteresting back view compared to her ‘cooler’ appearance.

    10. Keith M: No image this month

    ReplyDelete
  2. 11. Keith W: Keeping cool

    Intriguing image. I’m wondering if this was a special retro fashion occasion? Or a theatrical scene? I like the out of focus background but the facial lighting looks a bit hard and there is detail in the fan texture which could probably be brought out with more post processing. Did you take any other photos of the lady with different poses? This one is OK but there seems to be some potential for some different facial/character expressions.

    12. Malcolm R: Maiden Castle

    A good record but maybe needs to seen in a panel with other views of the landscape to be fully appreciated. On another day with better lighting the scene could be rendered very differently – particularly with some cloud detail.

     
    13. Michael E: Street shot Mykonos

    The image is far too busy to my eyes – too much to look at and to consider. There could be other possibilities for a more box office image – e.g ask the lady to move up a bit closer to the artist and picture them both from a closer viewpoint … with her Marlboro? cigarette packet more visible. The crying child and her mother departing are too distracting and alien to the main subjects.

    14. Phil C: 7 people, 6 legs, 1 broken

    I like the title – sounds like a good theme for a film. And I like the Boris bike. There is a story within the elements of the picture i.e people going about their business - to wherever - by themselves – no direct interaction - and unaware of the camera.

    15. Robert H: Steve Hart and Prize Angus

    A good record of a proud owner and his bull but I’d like to see a bit more of the animal’s girth ... and a bit more texture in its coat.

    16. Rob S: Anti-EDL Demo

    The photo could be sharper and could benefit from greater depth of field. The image captures something of the demo but I’d prefer to see a bit more action (the participants are not doing very much) and more of the rear banner. The invasive arm/hand on the LHS is distracting.

    17. Theodore D: Out to pasture

    The vintage tractor has a lot of potential for making a good / memorable image but this particular viewpoint does not do it justice. I suspect there is a lot more interesting detail to be captured from other angles.

    18. Tony M: Dunham Massey Park

    Interesting exploration of the M8’s IR imaging potential. I’d like to see more of the tree i.e. the whole tree. Unfortunately its foliage appears to be rather sparse. You’ve maybe not chosen the best subject for an IR photograph … the tree in the background looks to be a more photogenic IR subject with its fuller foliage. But good to see an IR picture included and hope to see more of them in future.
    .

    ReplyDelete
  3. 1) Bernd H:
    This is certainly very dramatic. I like the way the wooden ground leads ones eye into the distant gloom. The misty sea plus dramatic sky and wonderful lighting make for a very appealing seascape along with the bonus of the gulls to give added interest.


    2) Bill S:
    Good sharp result from the process you have used here. Lovely tones, shows what can be achieved with traditional methods. The choice of viewpoint gives maximum impact to the overall image.


    3) Dan B:
    Interesting image of a figure study. The single light certainly picks out your models form.


    4) David F:
    Certainly a colourful portrait! You have filled the frame with your intended subject and it looks as though she is oblivious of you. Pity about the girls bow behind her which is a bit distracting.


    5) David K:
    The ribbon of water along with the beached boat seem to compete with one another, as ones eye drifts up the stream then roams across to the yacht. However the light does pick out the textures in the wet mud.


    6) Duncan K:
    Well captured. I love the expression on the chaps face plus the lady making some sort of point behind him. Another quality image from the X1.


    7) Elaine J:
    The gravelled pathway is the first thing that draws your attention but it then pushes your eyes down to the couple on the grass having a break. A very simple picture with very few elements but it works.


    8) Howard F:
    Lovely peaceful photo. The deer do not seem to be fazed by your presence. It may have been worthwhile to concentrate on only one deer which would have made an even stronger picture.


    9) James C:
    The stark white background gives full emphasis to your chosen subject. The couple seem to be in deep conversation. I would have liked to see more of the mans face but that is not always possible under these circumstances.


    11) Keith W:
    This is a strong portrait with the light working for you here to illuminate the face. Choice of lens and aperture to throw the background out of focus strengthens the overall composition. A very appealing photograph.


    12) Malcolm R:
    A pleasing landscape of Maiden Castle but feel the flattish light has not done it justice. I think you could have cropped it at the base to remove the fence which would then give more emphasis to the trees which are more interesting. an image which is worth playing around with on the PC.


    13) Michael E:
    A lot is going on here but somehow it interlinks. The woman admiring the painting whilst the painter seems to be pleased with his work and the little child crying as though being ignored and then someone disappearing into the bushes. Is this a Bresson? I like it.


    14) Phil C:
    An interesting arrangement but The furthest figures do merge with the main characters in this image. A second or two later and they would all be separated which to my mind would give a better flow to the photo.


    16) Rob S:
    This is a good rendition of the Demo and you have captured it at just the right moment to give the viewer a snapshot of the event. The desaturated colour is an added twist.


    17) Theodore D:
    Certainly past it's sell by date! It is a pity the levers in the foreground are unsharp which jar on the image. The rest of the picture is good and sharp where it needs to be.


    18) Tony M:
    The IR works well here and the process brings out the clouds and sky behind the tree. a very pleasingly image.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Robert, and yes I agree. A split second later they would be separated, that's what comes of shooting on film and trying not to shoot too much. Cheers, Phil

      Delete
  4. 1. Bernd H
    Long exposure to smooth the sea and have cloud movement. It has good atmosphere although, maybe, a tad heavy in the shadow areas. Of course the gulls are a bonus and provide an element of amusement.

    2. Bill S.
    There are some dust spots etc. which need cleaning-up for best presentation. The wording of the sign is the strongest element but is it enough to make a satisfactory photograph? Maybe as part of a series but I am unconvinced in a single exposure.

    3. Dan B.
    Strong lighting on the model and the poses brings out the slim muscled body. There is a lot of tension in this image. I don’t think the inclusion of the light adds anything and would prefer to concentrate on the figure but including the full spread of light, i.e. 50% of what is shown here.

    4. David F.
    I guess a grab shot. There is obvious character in the closest woman with the tattoos and facial furniture. It’s a pity the far figure couldn’t have either been included to a greater extent or omitted altogether because that red ribbon draws attention away from the main subject which is the closest figure. I would wish for some toning down on the right and also the top left corner but do applaud that you have kept all the cigarette in the frame.

    5. David K.
    This seems a little on the soft side overall. It is a good subject but needed stronger lighting and a better sky than this bland one. Could I also suggest cropping out the buildings on the left to create a better feeling of isolation?

    6. Duncan K.
    A pleasing character study which tells a story. Sadly he is a little overwhelmed by the lady in the red frock; red being a dominant colour always draws attention to itself and, in this case, away from the main subject.
    Its typical of U3a recruitment events!

    7. Elaine J.
    A picture which poses questions. What and where are the tracks? Who are the people and how did they arrive here?
    A very good enigmatic image and a well chosen taking position.

    9. James C.
    Midland what? I like the simplicity of this image and that the glasses have been kept separate and also the interaction between the couple. The bland background is no problem in this image. Very pleasing angled lighting.

    11. Keith W
    The strong lighting has created a little of a problem here with some highlight issues on her skin and a rather obtrusive background. I wonder if she wouldn’t have obliged by being asked to move to a better position, people of there reconstruction events are often very obliging if asked nicely.


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Midland is a Restored Art Deco Hotel on the edge of Morecambe Bay, The shapes of the External and Internal are a gold mine for any photographer. plus wild life is in abundance in the bay.

      Delete
  5. 12. Malcolm R.
    A ‘general’ view as Chris Crosthwaite of fond memory would often say. There seems to be a lack of compositional lines which results in the eye dodging hither and thither around the frame. Reducing to just above the trees seems to me to make for a stronger image – but its your picture and you present as you wish it to be viewed.

    13. Michael E.
    You do your own critique! He seems a happy contented chap. For me the image is the painter and the seated lady. The crying child and rear view of the women bring intrusive elements and draw attention away from the main subjects. I would also suggest cropping out the part-door on the right because the markings on the glass draw attention to themselves. Nice quality image.


    14. Phil C.
    A street scene with quite disparate elements. You make the best of it with your amusing title. I wonder if a crop of the right to inside the bollard would ‘tighten’ the composition? For me, the post and bollard are not needed here.

    15. Robert H
    A happy farmer with his prize winning bull. The whites of the coat are just about held and this was not easy with the bull being black but enough detail is also seen in the dark coat.
    The oof background sets the scene and context. I have enjoyed looking at this double portrait.

    16. Rob S.
    A lot going on here with differing interactions.
    The various signs add to the story of the event though it does need your title to tell exactly what the demo is about. Good work.

    17. Theodore D
    A photographer’s subject. Old machinery is always an attraction.
    Good detail throughout through the oof items on the left are a bit of a distraction, especially the stalk and knob on the extreme left.. Just enough sky to set a context.

    18. Tony M.
    Good subject for infra-red work. A pleasing image and not a lot more to be said about it. Good work.

    ReplyDelete
  6. 1 Bernd H - A delightful image, beautifully produced and the framing draws the eye in nicely.

    2 Bill S - Good to see the use of one of the older Leicas and different film stock. Turned out well, lovely tones.

    3 Dan B - An impressive studio shot and a pose that’s different from the norm’. Works well.

    4 David F - Impressive tattoos and the framing shows them off well.

    5 David K - Lots to look at and I like the varied colours of the river bed.

    6 Duncan K - The woman in red makes this picture, in total contrast the quiet man reading his book. It’s a fun shot, not easy to achieve in these situations

    7 Elaine - Nicely framed, and the minimal number of elements in the frame work very well indeed.

    8 Howard - A nice shot of the deer who seem to be looking in different directions so I assume they were unaware of you.

    9 James - The lack of items in the frame is no barrier to enjoying this picture. I wonder what they are discussing. Probably asking who that chap is taking their photo.

    10 No image

    11 Keith W - A lovely portrait, nicely controlled depth of field and the black hat and fan complement each other well.

    12 Malcolm - I really like this. The different shades of the fields makes for a very pleasing picture.

    13 Michael E - I like this as well. It is s busy you really have to work to get at the elements, but rather than being a problem I think it is this that makes it work. Even the ground is a series of dots, not an inch is wasted.

    14 Me

    15 Robert H - A happy chap. A nice record of triumph.

    16 Rob S - Nice to see a shot from a demonstration. It works well in black and white though I think I would wat to go closer on the two in masks.

    17 Theodore - The tractor blends with the landscape, which is perhaps a fitting place for it to end its days.

    18 Tony - I think this is the first IR image we have had in Circle D. The subject is well chosen and the treatments works very well.

    ReplyDelete
  7. 1) Bernd H
    Fine composition and contrast but the long exposure and resultant effects do rather reduce the drama of the storm

    2) Bill S
    Interesting subject with good composition but the background does detract from the overall image

    3) Dan B
    Good lighting but it would have been preferable to see a larger image of the model and have the floodlight cropped out

    4) David F
    The photograph certainly reveals the tattoo patterns well but the background does rather detract from the overall strength of the image

    5) Mine

    6) Duncan K
    Well caught image of the man and a fun shot. His expression may possibly be showing a wish that the talkative woman behind him just ‘goes away’?!

    7) Elaine J
    Nicely composed photograph. Simple but effective

    8) Howard F
    Well caught shot of the stags, clealy taken with care as they do not seem fazed by your presence

    9) James C
    Nicely composed photograph with good lighting. Simple but it works

    10) Keith M - No image

    11) Keith W
    Nicely composed photograph with good lighting and depth of field

    12) Malcolm R
    Pleasing landscape photograph albeit the lighting is somewhat flat


    13) Michael E
    Well exposed and focused photograph, but it is rather busy with perhaps too much going on which detracts from the overall image

    14) Phil C
    Interesting street photograph resulting in perfect timing to produce the fun title

    15) Robert H
    Great shot of the happy and proud farmer with his prize animal

    16) Rob S
    Interesting shot of the demonstration but would have been strengthened by rather more action and drama. Also the arm to the left is distracting

    17) Theodore D
    Fine photograph of the vintage tractor. However, the lack of sharpness in the foreground is an unfortunate distraction

    18) Tony M
    Interesting picture of the tree but it is not for me as I am not a fan of infra-red images.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Keith W

    1)Bernd H
    I very much like the composition and tones, but for me the sky is much to heavy/dark.

    2) Bill S
    Well done on the process of getting this image to us, which you must find fun. The end result is a compliment to the pre-war optics.

    3) Dan B
    This would be a fine image in my view with the floodlight cropped out. As presented it feels like a text book on lighting illustration.

    4) David F
    The subject starring out of the picture jars. Nicely sharp with good depth of field.

    5) David K
    Any sort of tide would probably be good without the surge. Would a higher viewpoint have worked better?

    6) Duncan K
    Nicely caught moment of self satisfaction.

    7) Elaine J
    Good composition. Could figures be made a little brighter?

    8) Howard F
    A wonderful group to come across. I like the composition and its a fine image, but wonder if it would be stronger with focus on the first dear and the rest of the group slightly softer.

    9) James C
    I like this image and the shades of grey certainly work here. For me it could be improved further if it were possible to move left to separate the girl from the lamp post.

    12) Malcolm R
    I used to live in Dorchester on the road leading to Maiden Castle, and have been asked many times by visitors returning from the earthworks where the castle is, their expectation being some stonework. The dark clump on the left draws the eye, but good textures in a winter scene.

    13) Michael E
    Even with the narrative, there is to much going on in this scene for me. The artist is the interest and the lady on the bench is complimentary, but for me I don’t need the screaming kid or the rear view.

    14) Phil C
    Another well spotted fun image. Shame its all backs! Well done.

    15) Robert H
    A proud and happy chap. Did the local rag use this?

    16) Rob S
    Would like to see it cropped to two masked characters and the him and her bookends.

    17) Theodore D
    I very much like the idea and the composition, but for me the foreground must be sharp.

    18) Tony M
    Well done for trying something different and it works for me.

    ReplyDelete
  9. 1) Bernd H: I like the treatment and the effect of the long exposure. The eye is drawn into the distance by the fence and the seagull on his perch is a nice touch.

    2) Bill S: Wonderful image from vintage equipment, nice composition.

    3) Dan B: Great effect from the single light and I really like the fact that the light is as much the object of the photograph as the figure. Perfect exposure and tonal quality.

    4) David F: Interesting whacky subject, nice colours and composition. The outstretched cigarette sets the scene. It's a pity the figure behind the subject rather spoils the overall effect.

    5) David K: Good composition and colour and overall a pleasing shot.

    6) Duncan K: Taking his own medicine? I always like the IQ of the X1 and X2 and this is a nice example, particularly for an indoor shot.

    7) Elaine J: Nice story here: A couple sitting quietly and in harmony while the roads diverge. Well spotted and excellent composition.

    8) Howard F: Good wildlife shot, something I avoid because I'm useless at it. Nice composition and exposure, brave too.

    9) This shot has tremendous impact for me. I love the juxtaposition of the little table and the two people with the stark lines of the architecture. I find the left-hand lamp hovering over the subject's head a little disturbing and perhaps it would have been better to move a little to allow both lamps their own space. But a well-spotted and exposed picture.

    11) Keith W: I really like this shot, well focused subject and nice bokeh. The eye is drawn to the lipstick, a splash of bright red in the centre of the shot.

    12) Malcolm R: A good example of how a B&W landscape can bring out more interesting detail than your average colour shot. The tones here are exceptional and the composition well done. Instead of a big sky we get a big foreground which serves to put the trees and fields into perspective.

    13) Michael E: My busy little effort.

    14) Phil C: Well spotted but it needs the caption to bring out the story, especially at this size. Even without the broken leg I like the concept of everyone striding (riding) off in different directions bent on their particular bit of business.

    15) Robert H: A tale of two faces and I am not sure which has the most character. Good composition, and processing but the showman's unruly face and cheeky hat steals the show.

    16) Rob S: I like this newsy shot. I think I would have preferred to see the who central subjects occupying more of the frame but I understand why this wasn't done; the figure on the left is a bit distracting.

    17) Theodore D: Nice angle and composition, excellent clarity and tonal range. I tend to be a sucker for B&W conversions, so this shot pleases me.

    18) Tony M: On the subject of M&W conversions, this is an another good example and I love the IR treatment. Good detail in here.

    ReplyDelete
  10. 1) Bernd. A dramatic image that appears if anything to have been overworked (e.g. the haloes at the horizon and along the tops of the groynes). I like the way the groynes lead the eye into the picture and to those huge seagulls that cooperated so well by remaining in place throughout the long exposure.

    2) Bill S. I like the simplicity of this composition - and the oddball method used to produce the picture. The softness of the buildings in comparison with the sharpness of the barrier (I would have preferred a little more space to its left) gives a great feeling of depth to the image.

    3). Dan B. Quite an intriguing image. The inclusion of the spot light and the obvious tension in the model suggest the story of a photo shoot for a body builder rather than an ”ordinary” figure study.

    4). David F. Well, she is no blank canvas that’s for sure. The apparently equally patterned girl behind does confuse matters and I would like to see a little more space to the right but there appears to be other distractions that way as well so perhaps not possible.

    5). David K. The boat is certainly high and dry and looks a little uncomfortable on the sloping mudbank. The difference in the colour of the banks on opposing sides of the stream is quite remarkable and the yellow buoy in the foreground makes a good lead-in.

    6). Duncan K. He looks a tad lonely despite his list being full. The framing with the inclusion of the magazines, notices and all the background chatter really helps to tell the full story of registration day.

    7) Elaine J. I like the simplicity of this, the pattern created by the fork in the grey road intersecting the green of the grass. Backlighting and silver hair make the most of the two figures located in just the right spot.

    8). Howard F. Five of them in a nicely separated group - and not one with its back to you. A very pleasing picture, we rarely see these animals in such a relaxed attitude. I did wonder about cropping out the one on the far right and the tree stump but that would mean cutting through the next animal which would look odd.

    9). James C. Another delightfully simple composition. Two lamps, two heads, two glasses - even two hands, all in near monochrome apart from the red jumper. They are clearly deep in conversation and so the little story is well captured.

    ReplyDelete
  11. 10). Keith M. No image.

    11). Keith W. Shallow depth of field subdues the rather distracting background and leaves us in doubt as to the subject of the photograph ( a re-enactment?) The yellow poster/tinplate is particularly eyecatching but it is balanced by the yellow of the lady’s fan.

    12). Malcolm R.

    13). Michael E. A howl, a grin (or has he just got the sun in his eyes?) and a thoughtful expression, lots to look at here and we can build up our own story of what is going on and how the various characters relate to each other.

    14). Phil C. Neat. The triangular shadow of the roof (?) lines up exactly with the road markings and all the characters are reasonably well separated and heading in different directions. Is that a Boris Bike?

    15). Robert H. Now there’s a happy man with the sweet smell of success in his nostrils unlike his bull who has something less comfortable in his. It is a great portrait with story behind it. One very minor drawback is the proximity of the bull’s flank to the edge of the frame.

    16) Rob S. I don’t feel that this has really come off. The masked figures are intriguing and I like the use of the touches of colour in an otherwise monochrome image but it is far from clear what is going on (the NUT banner suggests some kind of teachers demonstration).

    17) Theodore D. I have to go along with previous comments on the out of focus knobs and levers, better to either keep them sharp or move forward a touch and leave them out of the frame altogether. It is a good subject to “explore” with the camera shooting from different angles etc. There seems to be a ghostly see-through wheel on the left that I find puzzling.

    18). Tony M. I.R. does a good job on skies but I can never get enthusiastic about the way it reproduces foliage, making grass look like snow. Here the main tree has been pruned left, right and top by the framing and at the same time obliterates the cloudscape.

    ReplyDelete
  12. 1) Bernd H. That is absolutely superb Bernd, composition, framing and processing – it’s all 1st class.

    2) Bill S. It only proves (again) that you don’t need million dollar kit to produce a fine image! 6 ISO – wow! Well done Bill.

    3) Dan B. I’d have liked a larger image to evaluate, however I do like the models poise and the excellent skin tones. Perhaps cropping out the light and darkening the left side would give a bigger impact?

    4) David F. Well spotted – there’s a lot to see on that lady!

    5) David K. A nice, and to me , tranquil scene with good composition – I suspect early morning?

    6) Duncan K. The title works very well for this one, amid the bustle around him the subject seems so removed from it all. Well seen and taken.

    7) Elaine J. A simple and very effective composition, for me the framing is just right.

    8) Howard F. That is a fabulous image of the stags, very well done indeed – sharp and the exposure is spot on.

    9) James C. A simple and uncluttered image, I like the composition very much

    11) Keith W. That is a lovely portrait, well exposed – it’s just a pity that the background is a little distracting – but I do understand you’ve got to work with what’s around you in this kind of situation. A WW11 re-enactment?

    12) Malcolm R. A very good shot of a wintery landscape – I like the line of bare trees, and the processing.

    13) Michael E. I’m jealous! It’s a great ‘street’ shot (for want of a better description) a great composition and Mm – well ‘nuff said – it produces superb photographs. A friend, from my club, has just got one and we had the privilege of seeing shots from his through our projector- super sharp and great tone. I’d like to see your photograph on a big screen. - Well done and enjoy the Mm (but I probably don’t have to say that!!)

    14) Phil C. Lovely, another fine ‘street’ shot, great exposure, processing and scanning, and It’s very amusing also.

    15) Robert H. What’s not to like about this – one happy man & one bemused bull, great stuff!

    16) Rob S. That’s a great reportage shot – the two masked demonstrators make it for me – have you tried a crop just of them? You will have had to be fast and alert in order to take this shot – very well done.

    17) Theodore D. I’ve always liked shots of old farm kit in this kind of distressed condition well taken and processed.

    18) Me

    ReplyDelete
  13. 1) Bernd H - Storm

    What a striking photo. Love the sharpness in the foreground, softness of the sea, shape of the barrier and three slightly unreal birds.

    2) Bill S - No stopping today

    THis works really well. A simple image with great depth of field.


    3) Dan B - Model: Joy

    Brilliant composition. Love the originality of this. The light and muscular body make it.


    4) David F - Tattoo patterns

    Tattoos and body piercings are so fascinating. For me I would have like to have her implied consent with an acknowledgement you were taking the photo but interesting nevertheless.


    5) David K - Awaiting a Tidal Surge

    Love the way you can see other boats, and boys, stranded but it doesn't grab my attention for too long I'm afraid.


    6) Duncan K - The Quiet Man

    A humorous observation, great expression on his face but too much going on in the background for me.


    7) Elaine J - Divergent

    What a great simple composition taken from an unusual perspective. Very nice.


    8) Howard F - Stags in Bradgate Park

    Feels too 'distant' and uncomposed for my liking. Wonderful animals though; always a joy to see.


    9) James C - Meeting at the Midland

    Looks almost like the people have been added afterwards; which is why this picture so interesting. I would like a little bit more information so I can make more sense of it though.


    10) Keith M

    No photo


    11) Keith W - Keeping cool

    Love the colours and the film quality of this photo. Depth of field is great and so is her expression. Nice photo.


    12) Malcolm R - Maiden Castle

    The black and white, for me, doesn't really help this photo. It's also looks slightly out of focus (but that could be my screen). I want to like it but it doesn't really capture the lovely countryside, and castle, that I know it is.


    13) Michael E - Mykonos

    Lots going on here which makes for an interesting photo. Why is the child crying, whilst the man, wearing a Mickey Mouse, laughing and the women looking surprised! But now I see the easel. I like the crop too.


    14) Phil C - 7 people, 6 legs, 1 broken

    Always love you mise-en-scène photos. Lots going on here but for me there are too many backs!


    15) Robert H - Steve Hart And Prize Angus

    Good meeting you last week Robert and this is a lovely portrait of man and beast.


    16) Rob S - Anti-EDL Demo

    Me

    17) Theodore D - Out to pasture

    I once found a lovely tractor in France. It was wonderful with its rust and colour. For me I want to compare this with that tractor and can't help think it would have benefitted from being in colour.

    18) Tony M - Dunham Massey Park

    Reminds me of the winter about to come. Looks like it was taken using infrared film. An interesting take on a normal photograph of a tree.

    ReplyDelete